|
Funded
Research Projects
The John
Templeton Foundation awarded grants in the amount of $10,000
to seven teams of teachers and researchers taking part in the Maxims
Research Grant Program. In support of their projects, each team
was awarded an additional $500 for the purchase of curricular resources
and materials.
The teams are
currently investigating how to best teach maxims, and they are examining
how meaningful and motivational maxims can be for students. Whether
you are a teacher, a student, a parent, or a researcher, we think
you will enjoy reading about each of the exciting research projects
and getting to know the grant recipients.
We welcome your
comments on the research projects, and you may send them to maximsnet@Templeton.org
Children
and Proverbs Speak the Truth: Teaching Proverbial Wisdom to Fifth
Graders.
Ms.
Deborah Holmes & Dr.
Wolfgang Mieder
Teaching
and Learning Maxims With Urban Youth
Mr. Matthew L. Davidson,
Dr. Thomas Lickona,
& Ms. Phyllis
Smith-Hansen
Teaching
and Learning Maxims from Proverbs, Ecclesiastes and Ethics of
the Fathers.
Mrs. Shalva Klement,
Rabbi Benjamin Samuels,
& Dr. Solomon Schimmel
Maxims
Matter to Me
Mr. Sterling Freeman,
Dr. James H. Johnson, Jr.,
Dr. Elizabeth Kiss, &
Ms. Melanie Mitchell
Integrating
Maxims with Cultural Identity in the Socio-Moral Development of
Eighth Grader Social Studies Students.
Mr.
David Borg, & Dr.
Larry Nucci
Maxims
and Moral Education: An Integrated Approach to the Thought of
Benjamin Franklin and Rabbi Israel Salanter.
Ms. Renée
Ghert-Zand, & Dr.
Carol K. Ingall
Teaching
and Learning Maxims With Urban Youth
Dr. Donald Biggs, &
Dr. Robert Colesante
Children
and Proverbs Speak the Truth:
Teaching Proverbial Wisdom to Firth Graders
Ms. Deborah Holmes (teacher),
Milton Elementary School, Milton, Vermont
Dr. Wolfgang Mieder (researcher),
The University of Vermont
Proverbs and
proverbial laws of life will be an integral part of Ms. Holmes's
fourth grade curriculum within a variety of projects. Students'
artwork will display illustrated posters; family, friends, and community
members will be invited to attend puppet plays and view students'
acting-out performances of maxims and proverbs. Animal related proverbs
will be researched and applied to science units, and other proverbs
from around the world will be employed during research in social
sciences, literature, and the mass media (proverbs in advertising,
caricatures, cartoons, comic strips, newspaper headlines, etc.).
By stressing the fact that worldwide laws of life in the form of
proverbs are indeed ubiquitous, the students will also realize that
this wisdom reflects common experiences and insights into human
nature. By emphasizing proverbs with strong moral messages in the
various teaching units, the teacher and researcher will engender
the positive character development of young students. Specifically,
maxims and proverbs will be utilized in an Ethics unit, a United
Nations' unit, and a Science/Math unit of study.
Teaching
and Learning Maxims with Urban Youth
Mr.
Matthew L. Davidson (researcher),
Doctoral Student, Cornell University
Dr. Thomas Lickona (researcher),
SUNY-Cortland
Ms. Phyllis Smith-Hansen
(teacher),
Lansing Middle School, Lansing, New York
The project
will engage a class of 6th graders at Lansing Middle School who
normally would take a yearlong life skills/character education course.
The project collaborators will select four character qualities that
are a good developmental match for middle school students, such
as positive thinking, perseverance, honesty, and kindness. Three
maxims for each of the four traits will then be taught to children
in the program group as part of their character education/life skills
course. Instruction will include a variety of methods--including
fables and true stories, classroom activities, history, current
events, interactive discussion, and homework assignments--to develop
cognitive understanding of each maxim, personal commitment to the
truth of the maxim, and behavioral practice applying the maxim.
For each of the four target qualities, students will select a favorite
maxim and copy it into their personal "Maxim-Izer" (an attractive
notebook provided to each student), rewrite the maxim in their own
words, explain in writing and to their peers in class discussion
why this maxim is their favorite, explain what the maxim teaches
about the related character trait, find historical figures who have
acted the maxim, select a person (parent, relative, coach, etc.)
they know who exemplifies the maxim, and write and present an essay
explaining how that person lives by the maxim in thought, word,
and deed. Parents of the participating students will also be involved,
documenting and assessing the impact of the project on their children.
Last, the researchers and teachers will produce a "Maxim-Izing Life"
video that will be used as part of the Center
for the 4th and 5th Rs training materials.
Teaching
and Learning Maxims From Proverbs, Ecclesiastes and Ethics of the
Fathers
Mrs.
Shalva Klement (teacher),
Prozdor Hebrew High School, Brookline, Massachusetts
Rabbi Benjamin J. Samuels
(teacher),
Prozdor Hebrew High School, Brookline, Massachusetts
Dr. Solomon Schimmel
(researcher),
Hebrew College, Boston, MA
The project
will develop, implement, and evaluate a course for teenage students
using biblical and rabbinical maxims, proverbs and aphorisms, to
teach ethical, moral and religious values of a universal nature,
as well as values and concepts specific to Jewish culture, religion
and civilization. Each class of 12-15 students will meet for two
hours per week for approximately thirty weeks. Students will study
and memorize maxims in their original Hebrew formulation in the
Bible and in post-biblical literature as well as examine different
commentaries on the maxims, which have been written over the centuries.
Students will also compare and contrast biblical and rabbinical
maxims with analogous maxims from English, American and other cultures.
They will also compare and contrast maxims within Jewish culture
and tradition that contradict one another. In order to acquire a
sense of how the maxims can be applied to specific life situations,
students will be asked to locate stories in newspapers to identify
current events to which the maxims they are learning could be applicable.
Students will be asked to keep a diary or journal throughout the
year to record real life situations in which they actually thought
about and applied the maxims they are learning or encounters where
they did not act in accordance with a maxim. All these strategies
are aimed at having students think about the maxims and their application
to their own personal lives.
Maxims
Matter to Me
Mr.
Sterling Freeman (teacher),
Durham Scholars Program
Dr. James H. Johnson, Jr.
(researcher),
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Dr. Elizabeth Kiss (researcher),
Kenan Ethics Program, Duke University
Ms. Melanie Mitchell (teacher),
Kenan Ethics Program, Duke University
A collaboration
of the Durham Scholars Program and the Kenan Ethics Program, the
project will take a group of sixth graders on a journey of self-discovery,
investigation, and collaboration to help them learn about maxims
as tools for life and strive to enable each child to develop personal
"ownership" of a maxim. At the beginning of the academic year, fifteen
students will be selected randomly from the thirty entering students
in the Durham Scholars Program. These students will proceed through
a series of modules -- Sampling Maxims, Choose Your Maxim, Getting
the Maxim Story, Maxims in Disguise, Making Maxims Move, Telling
the Maxim Story, Models of Maxims, Maxims Matter to Me, and the
Maxims Show. The Durham Scholars Program is a 20-year education
outreach initiative designed to foster college access and matriculation
among young people who live in six of the most economically distressed
neighborhoods in Durham, North Carolina.
Integrating
Maxims with Cultural Identity in the Socio-Moral Development of
Eighth Grader Social Studies Students
Mr.
David Borg (teacher),
MacArthur Middle School, Berkeley, Illinois
Dr.
Larry Nucci (researcher),
University of Illinois at Chicago
The goals of
the project are to (1) integrate the educational use of maxims into
the regular eighth grade social studies curriculum; (2) impact the
moral and character development of the children, and, (3) help bridge
the cultural values gap that exists between the white ethnic, African-American,
and Latino students at an ethnically and racially diverse middle
school. All project activities will be integrated within the regular
syllabus of the eighth grade social studies curriculum. The teacher
and researcher will engage the students to identify maxims from
African-American, Latino, Native American, and Euro-American cultures.
In general, maxims will be the focus of activity one day each week.
The teacher will strive to integrate maxims into normal homework
and grades assignments so that students perceive the "maxims activities"
as an integral part of the course itself. Each student will keep
all maxims gathered by the class in a separate 3-ring binder so
that the students will have this resource once the academic year
ends. The assessment activities associated with the project include
comprehension and application of the maxims studied, developmental
interviews constructed from a domain theory perspective, and a self-concept
interview designed to assess the manner in which morality is incorporated
into one's personal identity.
Maxims
and Moral Education: An Integrated Approach to the Thought of Benjamin
Franklin and Rabbi Israel Salanter
Ms.
Renée Ghert-Zand (teacher),
Solomon Schechter High School of New York
Dr.
Carol K. Ingall (researcher),
Jewish Theological Seminary of America
The teacher
and researcher will create a four week unit of study for juniors
and seniors in a Jewish day high school that will revolve around
the writings of Benjamin Franklin (1706-1790) and the father of
the Mussar (moral discipline) Movement, Rabbi Israel Salanter (1810-1883).
Both the free-thinking, deistic Franklin and the highly traditional,
decidedly theistic Salanter used the same techniques for improving
character: using personal notebooks, they each created lists of
virtues and attended to the attainment of those virtues by studying,
memorizing, and repeating maxims which concretized them. Students
will study, compare, and contrast the primary and secondary sources
on Franklin and Salanter, placing each in historical context. Each
student will be responsible for both an American civic virtue and
its Jewish equivalent, as well as maxims, which embody that virtue.
Each student will write a paper, which sets those maxims into an
historical, literary, and exegetical frame, exploring the personal
meaning of the maxims, and teaching them to the rest of the class.
During the unit of study, the students will keep notebooks in which
they will reflect on the virtue they have selected, their behavior
in light of that virtue, and the efficacy of their maxims to help
acquire that virtue. The culminating activity will be a Circus Maximus,
during which the entire school will circulate among learning stations
decorated with banners created by the students, based on their maxims.
Each artist will have an opportunity to discuss his or her banner
with the visitors. The banners will then be used to decorate the
school's new building.
Teaching
and Learning Maxims with Urban Youth
Dr.
Donald Biggs (researcher),
SUNY-Albany
Dr. Robert Colesante
(researcher),
Siena College
Colia Clark (teacher), biography unavailable
African Folklorist
Shirley
Jones (teacher),biography unavailable
State University of New York at Albany
The researchers
and teachers will design and pilot-test a model program to improve
the academic achievement and attendance of Albany's urban youth
by engaging them in a search for maxims about "Achieving Their Dreams."
The young people will collect, assess, analyze, and organize maxims
into a book of wise sayings for younger children. The program will
also provide an opportunity for adolescents to teach the maxims
to elementary-aged students. The researchers will collect, analyze
and report information on how urban youth of different ages rate
the credibility of maxims and the effectiveness of using stories,
poems, or music in the presentation of maxims. The researchers and
teachers will also organize a teacher's workshop in which participants
in the action research share their findings with a broader audience
of educators and youth.
|